10 Top Ways to Identify Scholarly Material

Facts about what is scholarly, and databases where scholarly things are found

Guide Overview

The "Week 5" page lists key library resources and facts about scholarly materials.  

 Email research@babson.edu to set up a consultation with a librarian. 

Authoritative

#1 HAS AN OPINION AND SOME WEIGHT 

Authority is derived from a well developed, balanced argument, and peer analysis. 

 Academic Search Premier - EBSCOhost

Examples: Search "society and TV"

Search "family and teen"

This one has pre-selected scholarly results for us. 

Authoritative

Accurate

#6 STATEMENTS HAVE BEEN CHECKED, VETTED, EDITED... 

Accuracy is related to authority. 

JSTOR  

 Examples: Search "education AND India"

Search "African Dance AND social aspects"

Always scholarly  

Accurate

10 Top Ways to Spot that it's Scholarly

Authoritative
Abstract
Adds to the Body of Literature
Long Length

References

/Footnotes

Accurate
Written by researchers
Advertisement Free
High vocabulary & reading level
Peer Reviewed

Abstract

#2 DISPLAYS A SHORT SUMMARY OF THE ARTICLE  

These allow publishers to organize and identify subject areas easily. 

Expanded Academic ASAP - InfoTrac

Examples: Search "brain drain"

Search "attitude"

Select scholarly as a limiter

 Abstract

Written by Researchers

#7 RESEARCHERS ARE ACADEMICS, PROFESSORS, SCIENTISTS... 

Their findings advance beyond what is known in the field

ProQuest 

Example: Search "immigration AND generations"

Search "women's studies"

Select  scholarly as a limiter

Written by Researchers 

E-Resources for Scholarly Journals

These are listed on the right in separate boxes, as well

Adds Something

#3 CONTRIBUTES TO THE BODY OF LITERATURE

Original thinking is what gets published. 

JSTOR 

Examples: Search "imperialism AND 20th century"

Search "beauty in victorian society"

This one is always scholarly

Adds to the Body of Literature

Advertisement-less

#8 NO ADVERTISEMENTS 

Related to BIAS.  This idea comes from publishers who feel they can print more freely when not indebted to sponsors.  

Project Muse

Example: Search "Bloody Sunday AND Ireland"

 This database is always scholarly. 

Advertisement Free



High Level

#9 ASSUMES READERS ALREADY KNOW SOMETHING ABOUT THE SUBJECT

 Academic Search Premier - EBSCOhost

Examples: Search "segregation AND busing"

Search "ritual"

This one has pre-selected scholarly results for us. 

High vocabulary & reading level

Long Length


#4 LONG LENGTH

Some are as short as 4 pages, most are 10 pages and beyond. 

Project Muse

Example: Search "Frankenstein AND Identity"

Search "landfill contamination"

This database is always scholarly. 

Long Length

Peer Reviewed

#10 JURY OF PEERS HAS REVIEWED THE ARTICLE

An expert panel of academics, educated in the same area, deliberate about the argument's truthfulness.  

Expanded Academic ASAP - InfoTrac

Examples: Search "fads OR crazes OR manias"

Select scholarly as a limiter

Peer Reviewed

References

#5 REFERENCES

You'll find citations for further reading at the ends of articles. 

ProQuest 

Example: Search "cultural identity OR cultural mistakes"

Select  scholarly as a limiter

References /Footnotes